Toronto Blue Jays' Rule 5 pick making a case for Opening Day bullpen

Both right-handers are vying for a spot on the Opening Day roster, and early on, Angel Bastardo appears to have the upper hand.

Through his first couple of outings, Bastardo has showcased an intriguing four-pitch mix.

His four-seam fastball sits between 93-95 mph, featuring fairly standard shape, but it sets up his true weapon, a devastating changeup that tunnels effectively off the heater and generates sharp vertical movement.

He also mixes in a slider, primarily against right-handed hitters, that shows roughly eight inches of glove-side sweep, along with a 12-6 curveball that works more north-south.

Toronto's plan was that Bastardo's arsenal would tick up in shorter bullpen stints once he was fully healthy.

Based on what he's shown so far this spring, that projection looks accurate. His stuff has translated well to relief.

The remaining question is command. While the raw arsenal is undeniable, consistency in the strike zone will ultimately determine whether he breaks camp with the big club.

His most recent outing against the Philadelphia Phillies was an encouraging step forward in that regard.

The roster battle isn't straightforward, though. Tommy Nance is out of minor-league options, meaning he would need to clear waivers if he doesn't make the team.

Over the past two seasons, Nance has quietly been one of Toronto's more reliable low-leverage relievers.

However, with diminished velocity and limited flexibility, he faces an uphill climb to secure a spot.

Adding another layer to the competition is Miles, the other Rule 5 selection in camp competing for what could be the same bullpen role.

Both Bastardo and Miles represent long-term upside plays, the kind of controllable arms teams are hesitant to lose.

With each appearance, Bastardo is strengthening his case. If his progress continues, the Blue Jays' decision-makers may soon be forced to choose upside over experience when final roster cuts are made.

Also read on Blue Jays Central :
Former Toronto Blue Jays who remain free agents heading into 2026 season