HOME     POLLS     SEARCH

TRENDING NOW


Interesting take on Toronto Blue Jays catcher Alejandro Kirk's legacy


PUBLICATION
Nelson Anderson
July 17, 2025  (9:05 PM)
SHARE THIS STORY
FOLLOW US

Toronto Blue Jays catcher Alexander Kirk
Photo credit: https://www.sportsnet.ca

Toronto Blue Jays catcher Alejandro Kirk is having a career season and is quietly earning a place amongst the clubs best catchers of all time.

Alejandro Kirk and Vladimir Guerrero Jr were the two players that represented the Blue Jays at this year's All-Star game which was Guerrero's fifth appearance and Kirk's second.

Alejandro Kirk being considered one of the best Blue Jays catchers of all-time despite only being 26 years old

Kirk is having a phenomenal 2025 season which resulted in him being selected to the All-Star team after hitting 7 homeruns and 45 RBIs with a .303 batting average in 81 games so far this season.
On the defensive side, Kirk has also being incredible due to his skills blocking and framing pitched as he currently has a .992 fielding percentage with only 5 errors on the season and 27 assists.
Sportsnet's Nick Ashbourne writes that, largely to this defensive contribution, primarily driven by blocking and framing, his career fWAR (13.1) Kirk is already second only to Whitt (21.1) among Blue Jays catchers. The same projection method used above to determine where he could land on the offensive statistic leaderboard indicates he should end his current contract with approximately 31 fWAR, a total that would put him head and shoulders above Whitt and the rest of the pack.

Due to his play this season with a incredible 211wRC+ and the fact that many would look at him as the team's MVP in 2025, he was recently considered one of the best catchers in franchise history.
He might just be the team's MVP in 2025, and the Blue Jays' decision to keep him in Toronto through his prime is looking better and better, writes Ashbourne. Not only does his contract ensure Toronto has a competent starting catcher through the rest of the decade, but it may have also locked in a historically significant figure for the franchise.

At this time last season, Kirk was hitting .234/.308/.323, and questions circled about whether he'd be able to handle a full-time starting catching job if Danny Jansen left in free agency.

Now, he's on track to go down as the best catcher in Toronto Blue Jays history

Ernie Whitt's longevity (1218 games in Toronto) and the 1992 World Series MVP won by Pat Borders are significant obstacles writes Ashbourne. Still, the combination of Kirk's stellar first half and the five-year extension he signed before the season put him in position to go down as a franchise great.

For such a young player, Kirk is already relatively high on the Blue Jays catcher leaderboards by most basic counting stats:
Thanks largely to this defensive contribution - primarily driven by blocking and framing - his career fWAR (13.1) is already second only to Whitt (21.1) among Blue Jays catchers. The same projection method used above to determine where he could land on the offensive statistic leaderboard indicates he should end his current contract with approximately 31 fWAR, a total that would put him head and shoulders above Whitt and the rest of the pack.

He might just be the team's MVP in 2025, and the Blue Jays' decision to keep him in Toronto through his prime is looking better and better.
Not only does his contract ensure Toronto has a competent starting catcher through the rest of the decade, but it may have also locked in a historically significant figure for the franchise.
POLL
JUILLET 17   |   201 ANSWERS
Interesting take on Toronto Blue Jays catcher Alejandro Kirk's legacy

Do you think Alejandro Kirk has the potential to be the best catcher in Toronto Blue Jays history?


BLUEJAYSCENTRAL.COM
COPYRIGHT @2025 - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
TERMS  -  POLICIES