HOME     POLLS     SEARCH

BLUE JAYS CENTRAL


Will the Toronto Blue Jays bullpen come around in time for the postseason?


PUBLICATION
Nelson Anderson
September 12, 2025  (1:30 PM)
SHARE THIS STORY
FOLLOW US

Toronto Blue Jays bullpen at Rogers Centre
Photo credit: https://www.mlb.com/

The Toronto Blue Jays bullpen has been a story of Jekyll and Hyde so far in 2025.

A group that was quietly a strength for this team through July, has stumbled in August and September so far.
There's some bad luck and bad timing involved here, given that a handful of key pieces are struggling at the same time, but there's also a common theme here, and there's nothing complicated about it.
Toronto's bullpen just isn't throwing enough strikes.
Getting Braydon Fisher back has been a big help help, and Tommy Nance has quietly been rolling with a 0.86 ERA over 21 innings.
Most importantly, Nance is filling up the zone and has walked just five batters over that span, and John Schneider continues to make one thing clear: If you want to pitch in big spots, throw strikes.
Hard-throwing right-hander Louis Varland looked better versus versus the Astros.
He twirled 1 1/3 shutout innings of work, one of the eight scoreless appearances from Toronto's bullpen against the Astros.
It certainly helped that Gausman took the bullpen off the table with Thursday's complete game, but the Jays' relief group appears much improved over the last two series.
The Jays' bullpen owns a 1.15 ERA in the last six contests, the second-lowest mark in the big leagues.
Brendon Little, Yariel Rodriguez and a refreshed Braydon Fisher had all thrown four straight scoreless outings.

Jeff Hoffman has taken two steps forward and one step back all season long for the Blue jays

The exception is Jeff Hoffman, the team's clear closer. After a scoreless 10-pitch outing in Tuesday's comeback win, Hoffman allowed a game-breaking solo homer in Wednesday's ninth-inning loss.
Jeff Hoffman was pitching for the third time in four nights & has given up 15 home runs, a record high by a Blue Jays reliever. Too much on both counts, IMHO. But who else in bullpen can close? 🤷‍♂️
That's the exact trend Hoffman's battled all season. He's rattled off lengthy stretches of dominance.
JEFF HOFFMAN STRIKES OUT THE SIDE TO GET THE SAVE ON HIS BOBBLEHEAD NIGHT ‼️
The strikeouts are high and the walks largely contained. Then he runs into a crushing homer.
Alright, #bluejays need to have a serious talk about removing Jeff Hoffman from the closer role...this is happening too often.
Schneider's diagnosis of Hoffman's homer issue is twofold. In part, it's teams preparing more aggressively for a closer, the manager said.
It's also pitch deployment, the sometimes ineffective sequencing of Hoffman's three offerings.
The Jays focused on Hoffman's pitch usage all season, attempting to correct the course.
It's not the first time pitch deployment has been mentioned as a potential fix, but the homers keep coming.
If Hoffman enters one of his strong stretches at the end of the season and carries it through October, the Jays seem to have the ingredients of formidability.
But the fear of one bad pitch in the ninth, and one big homer will undoubtedly remain.
Those lone mistakes are magnified in the playoffs. Avoiding that bad pitch could be the difference between moving on and planning vacation.
POLL
SEPTEMBRE 12   |   164 ANSWERS
Will the Toronto Blue Jays bullpen come around in time for the postseason?

Do you think the Toronto Blue Jays bullpen will come around in time for the postseason?

Yes11268.3 %
No2515.2 %
Too early to tell2716.5 %
List of polls

BLUEJAYSCENTRAL.COM
COPYRIGHT @2025 - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
TERMS  -  POLICIES